February 09, 2026

Sugar Cookie Protein Creami®

Say ILY with this new Sugar Cookie Protein CREAMi®! Snag the recipe and treat your heart out 💗

Makes 2 servings 
320 calories / 8F / 30C / 30P / per serving

12 oz. 2% milk
2 servings CSE Simply Vanilla Protein Powder
½ tsp. butter extract (optional)
2 Tbs. 2% milk
Toppings:
1 ½ Sweet Loren’s Sugar Cookie Dough balls
4 tsp. Bettergoods dye-free sprinkles


To make this protein-packed recipe, you will need a Ninja® CREAMi® Ice Cream Maker.

1. Add the milk, protein powder, and butter extract (if using) to a Ninja® CREAMi® jar. Froth until smooth. Cover and freeze overnight. 

2. Add the jar to the Ninja® CREAMi® Ice Cream Maker and spin on “Lite Ice Cream.” Remove and add two tablespoons of milk. Return to the Ninja® CREAMi® Ice Cream Maker and spin on “Re-Spin.”

3. Split into two servings and top with sprinkles and crumbled sugar cookie dough. Enjoy!

Link copied to clipboard!